Wednesday, February 25, 2015

A Helpful Analogy

What is minimum wage?

Question: What is the minimum wage and how does it affect the economy?

I think that everyone should be able to answer this question accurately and concisely.

Minimum wage is one of our most impactful economic policies. It applies to every economic activity that we engage in. It applies to every person who participates or who wishes to participate in the economy.

But the effects don't end there.

Minimum wage is not merely a social program or a form of assistance, rather it is a cultural norm enforced by law.

Minimum speed limit analogy

To illustrate the arbitrariness of minimum wage, and examine its unexpected cultural impact, it is helpful to use an analogy.

Instead of talking about economic activity, lets pretend we are talking about transportation.

Everyone uses different forms of transportation. Some people drive cars, others ride on buses, some people walk or bike, others take private jets, and a few people even orbit the earth in space craft.

The biggest predictor of how fast you are traveling is what form of transportation you use.
  • Walking: 3 mph
  • Running: 6 mph
  • Sprinting: 12 mph
  • Biking: 15 mph
  • City driving: 30mph
  • Freeway driving: 65mph
  • Commercial Airline: 500mph
  • Private Jet: 600mph
  • Space shuttle orbit: 18,000mph
  • Apollo 10 record: 24,000mph
Each activity serves a different purpose and each activity covers a different amount of distance in a different amount of time.

Now let's pretend, for a moment, that you want to improve people's access to efficient transportation.

You decide to create a minimum speed limit of 7.25mph on all city streets, roads, and walkways.

Most modern transportation activities will be unaffected. Cars rarely drive that slow, and cyclists and even skateboarders should be able to keep up without trouble.

Reasonably fit individuals can achieve that pace just by running.

For disabled people who can't walk, their powered wheelchairs can be designed such that they can comply to the new universal minimum speed limit.

The benefits would be numerous. People would get to their destinations faster, no one would be stuck being immobile or unable to travel because they were too slow to get to their destination quickly enough.

This minimum speed limit would help solve velocity inequality, where a small percentage of the world's population have a disproportinate amount of humanity's kinetic energy.

Eventually, we would bring this minimum speed law to less fortunate countries in Asia or Africa, where many people travel less than 10 miles a day. Some people even travel less than 1 mile in an entire day. Surely these people would be delighted to recieve a minimum velocity guarantee of 7.25mph.

A few people would complain about the drawbacks of not being able to go on leisurely walks, but those people are probably just pawns of elon musk, who wants to save all forms of high velocity travel for himself.

Surprisingly apt

The best way I can characterize this analogy is surprisingly apt. It is numerically insightful, because both economic and transportation activities involve exponential scales.

Athletes make millions while sustenance farmers only earn the food they eat. Spaceships travel at least 5 miles every second, while people walking take nearly 2 hours to cover the same distance.

This analogy also mirrors the differences we see across different countries. More people drive in the first world, and thus our average traveling speed is much higher.

The U.S. minimum wage may be low when you compare it to other 1st world countries like Australia, but in reality, half the people on earth live on $10 a day. A full billion people live on $1 a day or less. We can't arbitrarily enforce a "living wage" on these people.

It also highlights that differences in productivity that we realize are often due to different tools and techniques.

When you drive a car, it is easy to go 20mph. But only the fastest humans on earth can sprint over 20mph.

When you work in a factory, achieving a productivity level $20/hr should be easy. But if you try to cobble shoes by hand, it would be hard to keep up.

Just because we have modern technologies such as factories, doesn't mean that everyone has access to them, nor will everyone want to use them. Under our current system, a few people reap most of the benefit of factories, while other people are basically unaffected.

Finally, this analogy highlights the most important point I want to make. Minimum wage is not an effective solution to poverty nor is it an effective solution to wealth inequality.

Forcing people to run at 7mph doesn't fix anything. It won't give them good jobs if they don't have them already. It won't redirect resources away from space travel and private jets back down to earth. It won't create a blissful utopia with abundance and equality.

Perhaps there would be positive effects of a minimum speed limit. Perhaps more people would get in shape.  Perhaps it would improve congestion on the streets and city walkways.

But it would look ridiculously silly to have all those people running around for no apparent reason.

Final thoughts

Liberals have spent years fighting against unhealthy cultural norms, such as racism, sexism and more. They have fought uphill battles trying to ensure that people who are different have opportunities available to them.  It is unfortunate that these same progressive thinkers have become champions of a policy that partitions people based on their productivity level and enforces an arbitrary standard of productivity.

This simple wage limit, has helped create a culture where we universally both fear and hate economic activities that involve a low level of productivity.

In order to have value, in our culture, in the eyes of our society, there are currently 2 paths. One is to acrue social status or cultural influence, essentially fame. The other means of achieving societal value is by making a significant economic impact, essentially acruing wealth. Interestingly enough, the former can lead to the latter and the latter can lead to the former.

Individuals who fail to find a positive role within our society are generally looked down on. They are usually both misunderstood and feared and shunned. We create enormous pressure on ourselves and others to be high achievers, to find a worthwhile career where we have a positive sociatal impact and earn a decent amount of money.

But what do we really need?

There is a zen proverb that goes something like this: "Before enlightenment, chop wood, carry water. After enlightenment, chop wood, carry water"

I'll let you do with that quote what you will.

Friday, February 6, 2015

An Unexpected Utopia

Imagine a world where people give and take things freely, not demanding anything in return.  Imagine that you can walk outside, go anywhere, and recieve any type of good or service available, without owning or paying a cent.  Imagine that every person, rich or poor, could have anything they could possibly imagine.

This may sound like an unrealistic or far off ideal, but what if I told you it was not?  What if I told you that this kind of world took almost no effort to create, that in fact, we live in such a world already, all we have to do is realize it?!!

So what's the secret?

The secret is that information is naturally free to copy.

When it comes to physical goods, this type of free exchange is merely an idealistic fantasy.  But for information, the utopia is already here!  Information has never been more readily available, easier to create or easier to recieve.

I want to talk about copyright law.  I want to talk about patent law.  But in doing so, I don't want us to get hung up on these tiny details.  A world of free and bountiful information is already here.  Let's not forget what we have by focusing on what we don't have.

In the midst of such a utopian vision, intellectual property can look fairly petty.  We are so close to a beautiful and perfect world, why are these backwards thinking people insisting on holding on to an old, broken system?

But it's not so simple.  Information utopia may not be that far off, but a physical economy utopia is a long way from reality.  Worst case, it may never be practical.

In the absence of a universal utopia, the reluctance to embrace an information utopia is understandable.  Exchanging information may be practically free already, but creating it is not.  Individuals and companies use vast amounts of resources to conduct research or create media.  Expecting them to embrace a different vision for how information fundamentally works should not be done lightly.

But it needs to be done.

In the future, controlling the distribution of information will only become more and more costly, while the exchange of information becomes even cheaper and easier.

If this cost were only a monetary price tag, it might be justifiable.  It would certainly be expensive, but it might be justifiable.  But the cost is not merely monetary.  We pay the costs of intellectual property enforcement in many forms.  This includes personal freedoms.  It also dilutes and compromises the role of government, by committing us to policies that are unsustainable and counterproductive in the long run.

Let's look at the pirate bay.  Piracy is a clever and catchy term to describe copyright infringement.  In reality, the comparison to actual piracy is bit of a stretch.  But the pirate bay decided to embrace this term instead of rejecting it.

In doing so, they were effectively communicating a commitment to a course of action, that was independent of what the law said.  They became models of the principle of civil disobedience.

It is clear that the pirate bay website facilitated the infringement of US copyright laws.  Millions of people used that site across the world to help them download copyrighted media, including inside the US.

What is not so clear is whether the pirate bay itself broke any swedish laws.  I'll refer you to two resources if you want to know the details of this case.  The pirate bay article on wikipedia has a section titled legal_issues.  There was also an interesting documentary that was created that tells much of the history of the site and more importantly what happened to its founders.  Search for "tpb afk".

What is clear from those sources is that the enforment practices used to attack the site and its founders were highly questionable and at times unethical.  The case appears to have been pursued with significant pressure from the United States justice department.

You may not agree with the actions of tpb or its founders.  Fair enough.  But the point of this example is to highlight the challenges of copyright enforcement.  Tpb website was up and running before, during and after the trial.  The trial had no effect on the prevelance of copyright infringement.

The problem here is that copyright requires global enforcement.  And this enforcement is not possible without massive and intrussive surveillance, and other infringements into personal rights.  Are we ready to commit ourselves to a course of action that compromises our freedoms and helps perpetuate the surveillance state and government overreach?

Not all cultures and countries have the same attitudes and laws about intellectual property as our country.  Enforcing IP rules requires imposing our viewpoint on the rest of the world.  What if they are right and we are wrong?

What's my prescription?

I would actually like to recommend that people try to respect the wishes of authors of creative works regarding distribution and reproduction.  Being civil is important when you are trying to effect change.  In the words of one of my favorite philosophers: "Render unto ceaser, that which is ceaser's".  I don't think we need to buck against the commercial side of copyright law when it comes to entertainment media.

Having said that, I definitely feel that copyright enforcement is immoral, and impractical.  Thankfully, copyright law is hardly enforced beyond a domestic, commercial level.  Doing so would require unethical and irresponsible actions.  The exceptions to this enforcement pattern have demonstrated that.  The story of Aaron Swartz is a tragic example where malicious prosecution practices were used against someone who publicly put himself in the crosshairs by exercising civil disobedience on this matter.  He released a database of copyrighted scientific articles.  Aaron chose to end his life after rejecting a plea bargain, that, it could be argued, compromised due process by pressuring people to plea irregardless of guilt.

Aaron Swartz is a tragedy of the failings of public policy.  No one else made him kill himself, but that doesn't mean that the actions the justice department or the copyright holders are excusable.

A lot more can be said on this matter, but that is for another day.








Sunday, February 1, 2015

Three P's of starting a business

Let me start out by saying that running a business isn't for everyone.  I think that most people should work for someone else and can be perfectly happy doing that.  However, I also feel strongly that everyone should understand and consider the option of working for themselves.  Our rules should make it easy to work for yourself and that our culture should make it acceptable.

Even if you'd rather work for someone else, having the freedom to run your own business is important so that you have leverage when seeking employment.  If you are desperate, without good options, then you are stuck accepting whatever terms some employer dictates.  As you can see in my other posts, I feel strongly that the best way to alievate this predicament is personal empowerment, and being able to run your own business is one way to do this.


Personal Accountability


When you run your own business you are responsible for everything.  When you work for someone else, it is easy to forget or ignore everything that your employer takes care of for you.  Running a business is a lot more than the day to day work involved.  It's a long term commitment to your customers.  You have to be prepared to not only do the work, but to take accountability for the work that you do.  Your customers need to know what you offer and that you are consistent and reliable in delivering that offering.  If your mindset is "I want to try doing that", or "That sounds interesting", then you probably aren't ready yet to make significant commitments to customers.

A lot of people think of entrepreneurialism as a form of innovation, but in reality trying to innovate is unreliable.  Most successful businesses usually strive to serve people first, and then in the process of doing that they will innovate.  There is definitely an observation bias here, because the most visible successful enterprises are highly innovative, like apple, microsoft, or facebook.  These are the rare cases, and these kind of ventures tend to be much more risky than something like mowing lawns or walking pets.


Profitable


Your business has to be profitable.  If it's not profitable it's just a hobby.  It may be fun, rewarding, and even educational, but if it's not profitable it's not going to empower you economically.

Profitability is sometimes counterintuitive.  The unfortunate truth is that it is difficult to be sufficiently profitable creating and delivering necessities, especially for an unexperienced person working on a smaller scale.  Growing food or vegetables is a great way to save a little money, but trying to earn a significant amount of money doing it is challenging because raw food is so cheap.  Most commercial farmers cultivate acres of land and use expensive equipment and have large yields.

The same applies to other necessities like sewing clothes or making shoes.  Unless you can create something people are willing to pay a premium for, like organic food or trendy clothes, you will have a hard time making money.  In order to attract new customers, you must not only match the value and price of existing offerings, you actually need to do better.  Even if you offer a comparable product for a better price, a lot of people simply won't care enough to change their habits.  Even if they think what your doing is cool and they try your product, there's no guarantee they'll become long term customers.

Services are perhaps the easiest type of business when you are starting out small.  Large companies don't have all the advantages, small companies can offer better customer service and other advantages.  Paul graham, a famous tech entrepreneur, has an excellent article about this: Do things that don't scale.


Passion


The third P, and probably the least important, is passion.  Mike Rowe, the dirty jobs guy, has said something interesting, basically that you shouldn't follow your passion, but you should bring it with you.  Your business needs to be something you can be passionate about if you want to turn it into a long term success.  It doesn't need to be your dream job, but it should be something you care about and find engaging and worthwhile.






Saturday, January 31, 2015

The problem with Economists

I see 2 main problems with economists.

Amoral Science


One problem is that their field, like any other science, is amoral.  It is concerned with understanding how things work, but it won't tell you what is right and what is wrong.  This helps us understand cause and effect without bias, leading to more reliable knowledge, but doesn't tell us what to do.

Neutrality is important when acquiring knowledge, but the application of knowledge requires extreme prejudice and bias.  We need to decide what is right and what is wrong and actively support one side or the other.


Esoteric Shit


Economists study a lot of stuff, and it's stuff that is important in their field, but it takes true mastery to recognize the manifestation of simple principles in complex models.  This means while things may have complicated explanations they have simple explanations as well that are no less true.

If you read an earlier post I made, I talked about how in physics, analyzing the path of a projectile can be pretty complicated.  However, the most important information in many scenarios can be expressed with a simple, intuitive statement: "What goes up, must come down."

It's important that economists learn express their most important ideas in terms of simple principles, because they need to be able to engage with the public and policymakers on a level playing field.  We need many people actively involved in creating and negotiating our policies, including people without relevant advanced degrees.  If we can't make valid arguments about economic policies, then we are stuck with whatever the PhDs decide to tell us.

I like to think about the political and economic tumult in this country as a simple problem manifested on a grand scale.  The problem is this: who should take responsibility for what, and what will they do about it?  In a sense, it's simply a large scale version of what college roommates might experience trying to live together in an apartment.  Each person has different ideas of what needs to be done and how to do it, but each person needs to participate as well.  Sometimes there isn't a wrong way or a right way, but differing ideas create conflict anyway.

I  was trying to read Krugman's blog, he seems a smart fellow.  What am I saying?  He is smart and well qualified.  The little I could understand, he explains well with sound thinking.  He's a PhD in econ, and I'm an math undergrad dropout.

So what do I take issue with?

Krugman has the right answers if you want to understand how the federal gov't can take responsibility for our financial problems and fix them.  We need people like him.  The federal gov't can play an important role in how the economy functions.

What I am more interested in is what individuals can and need to do.  He's in the right position to do his job, and I'm in the right position to do mine.

One thought experiment that I use when reading economic shit is this: If people were immortal, and only consumed stuff for pleasure, how would that change this economic analysis?  In many cases it would not.  Measuring production and consumption usually doesn't care what or why.

Converting the words of people like Krugman about interest rates and quantitative easing into real world terms of mouths and food is a tricky exercise.  From reading his blog I'm convinced that he cares about the real world effects of economic policy and is willing to take a moral stand on issues.  I respect him even when I disagree.




Wednesday, January 21, 2015

Did minimum wage play a role in the 2008 financial crisis?


Have you ever set a goal that was too ambitious?  Perhaps the goal itself was not too ambitious, but you were overcommitted and underprepared.  You were going to be completely dedicated to changing your diet, or learning that language or fixing your budget.

The first week or so it might go great, while it's on the forefront of your mind, but then it gets harder.  You start to compromise or resent the expectations you created for yourself.  After a couple weeks, or maybe a month, or maybe more, you say "fuck it" and in a blaze of glory you burn down everything you were building.  Freedom, in the form of a box of donuts, never felt so good.

I don't have to tell you that people sometimes fail to keep their new years resolutions.  What is it about resolutions that look so good on paper, but are so hard to follow through with in reality?

People do keep their resolutions, all the time.  It is possible.  One thing it takes is maturity.  You have to set accurate expectations.  Your goal can be ambitious, but your expectations for the amount of effort and impact need to be accurate.  Change always requires sacrifice, it requires maturity to understand what that means.

Resolution keeping requires more zen and less zeal.  It requires patience and persistence more than it requires passion.  Most of all, it requires an accurate understanding of your true priorities.  If a competing interest is more important to you, your resolution may get compromised to pursue that other priority.

Wait, didn't you say that this post was about minimum wage and the 2008 financial crisis?

That's what I'm trying to tell you, that's exactly what I've been talking about.

Minimum wage is like a new year's resolution for the entire country.  Okay guys, everybody is going to earn at least $10.50 next year.  $10.50 is reasonable, it's not too ambitious, and it's very important.  We should make it a priority.  Business owners and employers, employees, all of you, big or small, successful or struggling, let's make this your #1 priority.  We'll even offer to help guarantee you have enough incentive!  If you don't meet that resolution, we take you to court and shut you down.

Let's rewind.  It's 2007 and the federal minimum wage has been $5.15.  Over the next couple years it gets bumped up to $6.55 and then $7.25.

But did this bump cause the financial crisis?  Claiming that would be a classic case of post hoc ergo procter hoc (I've been watching me some west wing).  Just because the crisis happened right after the bump, does not mean that the bump caused the crisis.  In fact, I think that in this case it is evidence that the bump did not directly cause the crisis.  The mechanisms that triggered the crisis were already in full swing when the bump happened.  At most the bump was straw on the proverbial camel's back.

So why am I entertaining the notion that minimum wage was an important factor in the crisis?

Subprime loans.  Subprime loans.  Subprime loans were a massive trojan horse for an army of irresponsible financial practices, metrics and mathematics that obfuscated risk instead of clarifying it.  I would encourage you to watch the TARP documentary by PBS frontline for all the nitty gritty details.

Suffice it to say that our most trusted, beloved institutions, the stewards of our dollars, were hiding their messes instead of cleaning them up.

But the pretext for these shenanigans was subprime loans.

Before the crisis there was a big push for home ownership.  Politicians, public servants, and activists were pushing to give everyone the opportunity to experience the American dream in the form of home ownership.

Financial instutions responded by expanding their lending practices.

What does this have to do with minimum wage?

Only this: minimum wage is a politically backed guarantee for better lifestyle.

I think the existence of minimum wage is one thing that may have made it risky to lend to poor people in the first place.

Minimum wage places strict constraints on what people can do to earn a living and it's especially limiting to the poor or disadvantaged people.  If you have ever gone looking for a minimum wage job you know that they suck.  The bosses don't treat you that well, they have lots of turnover, the people who take those jobs tend to less reliable.

Some people interpret this as a sign that minimum wage is not high enough, but I think it's really a sign that minimum wage is very limiting.

New workers and disadvantaged workers need opportunities that fit them well.  Not all these opportunities will pay great, but they give these individuals opportunities to be beneficial to an employer, to understand how the workplace works, and to understand their job needs and priorities.

If people have a positive experience working, they will increase their experience and value to their current employer and potential employers.  I think a lot of those who struggle have negative experiences with employment.  They become frustrated and disillusioned.  Can we blame them?  Most of the low wage jobs out there suck.  They are thankless and soul sucking.  They involve activities like stuffing cheap plastic toys from china into bags with unhealthy meals for kids.  I mean who wants to do that?  Fuck that.

If we want to help improve the lives of low wage workers, we need abundant opportunities doing important and rewarding things.  Politicians love talking about adding jobs to the economy.  They talk about jobs as if we should be grateful just to have one.  We have started thinking like there should be a 1 to 1 relationship between jobs and people.  That for every one person there should be one job.

Let me tell you, that is not nearly enough.  Having only 1 job available for every 1 person in an economy has a name.  That name is slavery.  If you don't have lots of options, you have no freedom.

One job per person is not enough.  We need 10 available jobs per person, or 100 available jobs per person or 1,000 available jobs per person.  We need real market choice for what we do to earn a living!

When people don't have real choice they don't have freedom.  They become frustrated and unreliable.  They become targets for well intentioned home ownership campaigns.  When they get told they should sign this loan to get a better life, they do it, even when the conditions are shit.  When someone has been kicked around and shitted on, something like that can seem like a lifeline.

Minimum wage affects jobs well above its payscale.  It creates a universal fear of failure from the bottom to the top, because we all know what the bottom looks like and it's not good.

But the bottom doesn't have to be ugly.  The bottom doesn't have to be feared and shunned.  We can be poor but free.  And when we are free, we are free to become rich.  We can choose our own priorities and we can make our own new year resolutions.









Tuesday, January 20, 2015

Subjugation in the Modern Economy

What is subjugation?


The word subjugation comes from the same roots as the word subject.

When I hear the word subject, it makes me think of peasants in a fairytale kingdom.  Many fairytales describe a benevolent king and queen and a kingdom of loyal subjects.  Sometimes I suspect that fairytale stories may be propaganda created to promote medieval systems of government.  Fairy tales often present an idealized version of monarchy, where everyone is happy playing their specific role in the kingdom.  Most likely, these stories weren't actually created for propaganda purposes, they merely reflect the ideas people had about government at that time. The stories we tell reflect the way that we see the world.

Like so many other words, the words subjugation and propaganda have strong negative connotations.  These negative connotations come from, in part, the potential for abuse.  Propaganda is associated with corrupt political systems, including Nazi germany, where it was used to help citizens ignore the abuse and murder of millions of people.  Subjugation is associated with slavery, a condition which millions of people have experienced, where their basic freedoms and human dignity were denied them.

Not all propaganda is bad, and not all subjugation is slavery.  Propaganda is merely self promotion by political or governmental entities, subjugation is any enduring relationship where one person has authority and the other party is subservient.  Naziism and slavery are extreme examples of each.

As many fairy tales are eager to point out, subjugation does not always completely strip human dignity or remove all human rights.  Authoritative governments sometimes allow their subjects to retain a great degree of individual freedom and self-determination.  However, what may have been an ideal government hundreds of years ago is not necessarily excusable today.  No form of subjugation, no matter how mild, is acceptable.  Modern government needs to help protect and respect all human rights.  Not all potential freedoms are human rights, but rights include everything needed to preserve an individual's freedom of conscience, expression, and self-determination.   Some forms of subjugation may not rob people of all their rights, but subjugation always takes away at least one or two basic human rights.  

In the modern world, subjugation definitely exists.  This includes extreme and deplorable examples of subjugation.  There are still people living in slavery.  Practices such as human trafficking and sex trafficking still happen in the world we live in.  We should do what we can to become educated about these issues and be willing to go to extreme lengths to end these practices and apprehend those involved.

There are also less extreme examples of subjugation and abuse that need to change.  The most prevelant form of subjugation in the modern world is economic subjugation.  Our economic systems greatly benefit some people while others struggle to survive, sometimes unsuccessfully.  Contrary to what most people would suggest, I believe that the vast majority of people in economically advanced contries, especially the middle class, participate in practices that lead to the economic subjugation of others.

The super-rich may be guilty, but the medium rich are guilty as well.  This includes every middle class person in the first world.


Identifying Economic Subjugation


Before we can fix the conditions of economic subjugation, we must identify where and why subjugation exist.  More importantly, we must identify our role in the process and what we can do to change.

How can I tell if I am subjugating other people?  How can I tell if I am reducing the economic freedom of another person and forcing them to become subservient?

I have a test I would like to propose.

This test is not perfect, and if anyone has a better test, I would love to hear it.  This test has specific weaknesses, some of which I will explain.


The subjugation test: "Do you help produce basic necessities?"


In order to survive, there are a few basic necessities that every human being absolutely needs.  We cannot live without food and water.  Shelter is an important tool for survival because it protects us from the elements.  Shelter also allows us to create a protected area to ensure the safety of ourselves and our loved ones.  Clothing, like shelter, is important for protection from elements.

These are the basic necessities: water, food, shelter, clothing.

There are a lot of other important things, many of which may contribute to survival.  But these are absolute prerequisites.  If you hope to survive, these things are absolutely necessary.  While other goods and services may be useful, they are not required in all survival situations.

The subjugation test is a simple question: Are you involved in the production of basic human necessities?  Everyone needs these items to survive, everyone consumes these items.  If you aren't doing anything to help produce these survival items, then someone else is doing that for you.  Are the people who produce your basic necessities getting fair value in return?

At this point, you may want to make arguments about trade and division of labor.  These are great tools, and I think we should use them.  However, I want to suggest that unless you can account for the origins of your basic necessities, there is a good chance that people are being taken advantage of somewhere along the way.

Why this assumption? Why do I just assume that some people aren't getting fair value in return?

My assumption is based on human nature.  Human nature is a pretty consistent thing.  When someone is struggling to survive, the first thing that they care about is basic human necessities.  They won't care about anything else until their basic necessities are met.  Specifically, that person doesn't care about whatever goods or services you are providing to the economy.  But their work goes to serve your basic necessities.  

Somehow the value isn't coming full cirlce.  They are working for you, but you are not working for them.  That is the definition of subjugation.

Until every able-bodied person has reasonable opportunities to participate in the production of basic necessities, there is enormous potential for economic abuse.  How does this abuse occur?  Anyone in an economically secure position will use the necessities of others as leverage to get a better deal on the things they want.  So long as some people are struggling to secure basic necessities, everyone else in an economy, not just those with great wealth or power, will take advantage of the disadvantaged people.  When people are disadvantaged, everyone else in a marketplace will unconsciously take advantage of them.

When people are disadvantaged, everyone else in a marketplace will unconsciously take advantage of them.

Ideally, the best way for disadvantaged people to secure basic necessities is by participating in the production of basic necessities.  Access to the production of necessities is just as important as access the necessities themselves.  This is the only way to scale the jobs available to match the needs of the economically disadvantaged.

Access to the production of necessities is just as important as access the necessities themselves.

Should the economically disadvantaged be working in call centers?  Should they be washing dishes in restraunts?  Should they be cleaning corporate office buildings?  Should they be landscaping corporate properties and cleaning hotel rooms?

If they want to do this kind of work, they should be able to do these things.  But the one thing that all these jobs have in common is that they are providing goods and services that they themselves can't afford.  This sounds like economic subjugation to me.  At this point it's not about specialization or comparitive advantage.  At this point some people are the servants and some people are the masters.

In order to remedy this, the economically disadvantaged should always have numerous options to be more directly involved in the production of their own basic necessities.  These opportunities should be available to everyone, rich or poor, to help create the basic necessities that they rely on to survive from day to day.


These opportunities should be available naturally without relying on the creation of specific governmental programs to create these opportunities by mandate.  However, the government could play an important role by spearheading research and experiments that would shed light on how economics and government affect the availability of these kinds of opportunities.

Weaknesses of this test


As I mentioned before, this test is not perfect.  Specifically, it can be hard to distinguish between economic cooperation, such as trade and specialization of labor, and economic subjugation. 

Economic cooperation is where people take on different roles based on what they are good at and what they prefer to do.  Economic subjugation is where some people control or manipulate the choices that are available to other people for the latter's benefit.

What makes it tricky is that economic cooperation and economic subjugation often look the same on the surface.  What people do for a living doesn't automatically tell us whether they are being subjugated or not.

But the point I want to make is that the availability of different kinds of work can be a strong indicator of subjugation when the markets are being manipulated.

Specifically, jobs producing useful and essential things should be readily available.  Furthermore, the amount people earn doing these jobs should be roughly proportional to the amount they create.

There is a important tradeoff invovled that we need to be aware of.  This is the tradeoff involving infrastructure, productivity, and profit shares.  More infrastructure (factories, supply chains, expensive tools and machines) helps make people more productive, but at the same time, when that infrastructure is owned by someone else, the individual worker gets a smaller share of the profits.

For example, when you work in a factory making shoes, you make a lot more shoes than you would working alone, but when you work alone you get 100% of the profit.

The optimal scenario probably involves something in the middle.  Individuals should have the flexibility to determine whether they work for a big corporation, whether they work for themselves, or whether they do something in between.  They should also have enough flexibility to work on things that they feel are important, that provide real benefit for themselves or others.

When this is not the case, something is definitely wrong.


Relevant Links

http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/sep/07/column-change-life-bullshit-job